Home / Trades / Grading & Earthwork

Grading & Earthwork: what bids leave out

Grading bids are where the spread between bidders is often widest, and the reason is rarely price. One bidder carries finish grade and SWPPP but excludes staking, testing, street cuts and seeding. Another carries rough grade only and excludes topsoil, finish grade and granular fill. On paper the low number wins. Leveled, it may not.

Level your grading bids with this checklist →

Standard scope checklist

Send this to every bidder and ask them to mark each line Included, Excluded or give an Add $. Silence is not inclusion.

#Scope item
1Mobilization / demobilization
2Construction staking & layout (who pays the surveyor)
3SWPPP plan preparation and permit filing (NOI / NOT)
4Erosion control install & maintenance (silt fence, inlet protection, rock entrance)
5Clearing & grubbing
6Demolition of existing site features (pavement, curbs, slabs) & disposal
7Topsoil strip & on-site stockpile
8Cut / fill to rough grade per grading plan
9Import fill: quantity and material spec
10Export / haul-off of excess and unsuitable soils
11Moisture conditioning & compaction to spec
12Density / compaction testing
13Subgrade prep & proof roll for paving and slabs
14Undercut & replacement of unsuitable soils (unit price)
15Granular fill / aggregate base
16Finish grading to tolerance
17Topsoil respread or import of black dirt
18Final stabilization: seed, sod or erosion control blanket
19Dewatering
20Rock excavation (unit price)
21Street cut, pavement removal & patch in right-of-way
22Right-of-way / street cut permits & fees
23Handling spoils generated by other trades (utilities, footings)
24Dust control & street sweeping
25Sales tax, prevailing wage & performance/payment bond

Common exclusions and how they are worded

ExclusionTypical wordingWhy it mattersTypical cost to cover
Construction staking
  • “Excludes staking”
  • “Layout by owner's surveyor”
Someone has to set grades before the dozer moves. If no one carries it, you pay your civil engineer or surveyor separately, usually on an hourly basis, and grading can stall waiting for stakes.TBD
Compaction / density testing
  • “Excludes testing”
  • “Testing by owner”
Testing is normally an owner-hired third party, but you must budget it, and failed tests mean rework. Make sure the bid says who pays for re-tests.TBD
Topsoil import / black dirt
  • “Excludes import black dirt / topsoil”
  • “Topsoil by others”
If there is not enough on-site topsoil to respread, importing it is a real line item that landscaping bids also tend to exclude. It can fall between two trades.TBD
Finish grading
  • “Rough grade only”
  • “Finish grade by others”
  • “+/- 0.1 ft rough grade”
Rough grade vs. finish grade is one of the biggest scope differences between grading bids. A rough-grade-only bid will look much cheaper than one carrying finish grade.TBD
Granular fill / aggregate base
  • “Excludes granular fill”
  • “Aggregate base by paving contractor”
Base rock under paving or slabs can sit with the grader, the paver or the concrete sub. If everyone excludes it, it is a gap.TBD
Spoils from other trades
  • “Spoils from other trades not included”
  • “Handling of utility spoils by others”
Utility trenching and footing excavation create dirt that has to go somewhere. If the grader will not handle it, the utility subs need to carry haul-off, and they often exclude it too.TBD
Erosion control blanket & seeding
  • “Excludes erosion blanket, seed”
  • “Final stabilization by landscaper”
Your stormwater permit cannot be closed until the site is stabilized. Someone has to seed or blanket disturbed areas, and it is commonly excluded.TBD
Street cuts, removals & permits
  • “Excludes street cut permits”
  • “Excludes street removals”
  • “Excludes pavement patching in ROW”
Work in the public right-of-way brings permits, inspections and city-spec patching. It is easy to miss and slow to permit.TBD
Tax, bonds & prevailing wage
  • “Tax, prevailing wage and bond not included”
  • “Can provide bond at x% of contract”
A bid that excludes the bond and tax is not comparable to one that carries them. Add the quoted bond percentage to the bid before comparing.TBD
Dewatering & unsuitable soils
  • “Excludes dewatering”
  • “Unsuitable soils removal at T&M”
  • “Excludes rock”
These are risk items. Ask for unit prices up front so a wet hole or soft spot does not become an open-ended change order.TBD

“Typical cost to cover” is TBD. We will publish ranges only once we have real, sourced data. Until then, use your own estimate or a confirmed add price from a bidder.

Questions to ask bidders

  1. Is your number rough grade only, or does it include finish grade? To what tolerance?
  2. Who provides construction staking, and how many re-stakes are included?
  3. Does your SWPPP scope include the plan, the permit filing, inspections, maintenance and final stabilization?
  4. What import/export quantities did you assume? Please give a unit price for additional import and export.
  5. Will you accept and haul off spoils from the utility and footing trades?
  6. What is your unit price for undercutting and replacing unsuitable soils?
  7. Is the bond included? If not, what percentage would you add?
  8. Does your price include any work, permits or patching in the public right-of-way?
Placeholder

Bid-ready grading contractors

Contractors who agree to price against the standard checklist above, with exclusions spelled out line by line. Listings are not live yet.

Featured listing

Your company · City, ST

Bids on the BidGaps checklist

Featured listing

Your company · City, ST

Bids on the BidGaps checklist

List your company →